As men slowly wade into the wide, wide world of moisturizers, they’re encountering an epic array of choices.
It’s a very competitive market. And there are plenty of good products out there, along with some suspect solutions that should probably be eliminated from consideration immediately.
So let’s consider two of the best—Kiehls vs Jack Black.
Specifically, we’re talking about Kiehl’s Facial Fuel Energizing Moisture Treatment and Jack Black Double Duty Face Moisturizer, of course.
They’re both excellent products that rate high on the quality scale. But there are also some differentiating factors that simplify the decision.
What follows is a breakdown of ingredients and pricing, along with a final verdict based on effectiveness.
Kiehl’s vs Jack Black: Which Should You Be Using?
At this point, both brands aren’t strange to you. However, there has to be a better brand for you to choose. I for one will have to go with one since I don’t have the budget for the two.
So, let’s look at the ingredients and see if there is a winner.
Ingredients
Reviewers agree that these are both good products, so we’ll deal with Kiehl’s first.
There’s a reason this company’s products consistently turn up near the top of all the listicles out there about men’s moisturizers.
And it mostly has to do with high-quality ingredients designed to create the impression of a luxury product.
For the moisturizing treatment, the key ingredient is chestnut, and the selling point is that it’s rich in antioxidants that help neutralize those evil free radicals that are always demonized in all those holistic product descriptions.
Kiehl’s Facial Fuel Energizing Moisture Treatment also contains what’s described as a “jolt of caffeine,” so if you missed your morning joe you can always take it in the chin, so to speak.
Jack Black grooming products are also big among the male moisturizing set, and the cool product name is only part of the story here.
JB is out to create a specific aesthetic to go with the high-quality ingredients, and the overall success of the product line is clear evidence that the storyline works.
Jack Black Double Duty Face Moisturizer goes for more of an organic approach than Kiehl’s, hanging its hat on blue algae extract, along with other vitamins and minerals designed to hydrate and soothe.
The idea of lathering up with algae may sound a little yucky, but this extract is full of Vitamin E, which has a proven track record in skin care.
And the SPF rating of 20 gives you a fair level of sun protection as well.
Unfortunately, some of the reviews of this Jack Black product mention that it can be slightly abrasive, which gives Kiehl’s the nod here.
Do They Test On Animals?
I like that Jack Black has a strict stand on animal testing. Aside from selling its products in Mainland China, Jack Black is entirely against animal testing.
So, if you’re looking for a cruelty-free brand, you may want to consider investing in their moisturizer or other products.
Most Jack Black products, including the Jack Black Double-Duty Face Moisturizer, feature the PureScience formula.
This formula is free from parabens, fragrances, silicone, and colorants. But rather containing organic and plant-derived ingredients.
Kiehl’s, on the other hand, often has formulas that contain parabens, PEGs, and a few other questionable chemicals.
Pricing
The pricing floor here is similar, with both products starting at just under $30.
Depending on where you look for Kiehl’s, though, it can get a little more expensive, with listings as high as $40 or so.
Packaging
As usual, the Kiehl’s Facial Fuel is available in a tube. Size varies from 2.5 oz to 4.2 oz to 6.8 oz.
Jack Black, on the other hand, comes in a bottle that is available in 1.5 oz, 3.3 oz and 8.5 oz bottles.
Comparing both brands based on prices, there are very similar even though Kiehl’s might be a little pricey.
In terms of convenience, I’ll give it to Kiehl’s. The tube is easier to store or travel with (if you’re constantly on the move).
It’s also easier to dispense than a bottle, just flip the top open and squeeze and you have a dash of cream on your hands.
If you have limited space in your bathroom, you might want to go with Kiehl’s since that’ll help you save space.
Frequently Asked Questions About Both Brands
Can these products be used by women?
No, both Jack Black and Kiehl’s moisturizers are formulated for men only. Some women actually use either of the two.
However, it may not bring the desired results since men’s skin is a different beast from that of women.
If you’re a woman reading this, just buy it for your husband. That way, you won’t miss a beat!
What is Kiehl’s Facial Fuel used for?
It’s used for soothing the skin and making it feel comfortable all day. This is possible, thanks to a combination of vitamin C & E and caffeine in the formula.
The Verdict
Despite the slightly funky pricing, Kiehl’s is still the winner.
There’s nothing wrong with the Jack Black product if brand loyalty is a thing for you, but if you can find the Kiehl’s it represents a better way to go.
Up Next: Brickell vs Jack Black