Sudsy Bear vs Dr. Squatch: Which Is Better?

Sharing is caring!

As a man, you need to prioritize soap that does not only cleanse your body but hydrate, nourish and moisturize it. There are many soap brands in the market now and finding a good one could be tricky.

Luckily, compared to a few years ago, we now have some all-around body bar soaps designed for men to achieve that smooth masculine skin every man desires.

Sudsy Bear and Dr. Squatch are top brands that have made a name for themselves in this industry.

In this article, we will be comparing their popular products Sudsy Bear Rum and Dr. Squatch Bay Rum Soap.

What are their benefits? Their Ingredients? Which is the better Soap? Which is perfect for your skin and which should you buy?

Keep on reading as we compare and contrast these products.

Sudsy Bear vs Dr. Squatch: Overview

Sudsy Bear Bear Rum Soap is an all-in-one bar soap formulated with natural and organic ingredients.

The soap is designed with men at heart but that doesn’t mean women can enjoy its delightful smell and shower prowess.

The soap contains natural ingredients that help to hydrate and moisturize the skin.

Perfect for all skin or fur types, this soap will leave your skin very smooth and scented with its delightful smell of crushed cloves and cinnamon sticks without leaving any dryness.

Dr. Squatch Bay Rum Soap is made with the best natural ingredients and essential oils to remove dirt and any other unhealthy things on the skin.

The combination of all these natural ingredients is perfect for moisturizing the skin and giving you a clean body.

Its gritty composition knocks out every grime and stinks from the body. The soap won’t leave the skin dried out while reducing the oily composition of the skin.

Key Ingredients

Sudsy Bear Rum Soap is a man-made product formulated with natural ingredients containing Saponified Oils of (Coconut, Castor, Olive and Sustainable Palm), Mango Butter, Organic Shea butter, Sweet Orange, Clove, Pumice Sand, Pine Kaolin Clay and Sea Salt.

Kaolin Clay has substantial skin benefits. It detoxifies, cleanses and Exfoliates skin while reducing the oily component of the skin.

Dr. Squatch Bay Rum contains similar natural and moisturizing ingredients with Cedarwood and Fir Needle Essential Oil making up additional ingredients.

The FIR needle essential oil helps to relieve tension and encourages relaxation. CedarWood promotes an even tone in sensitive areas of the skin.


Sudsy Bear Rum has a refreshing smell of Cinnamon, cloves, crisp southern pine and zesty orange.

In the same vein, Dr. Squatch Bay Rum has an all-natural fragrance smell that contains hints of citrus, pine, cinnamon, and clove.


If you check the respective brands for each soap, you’ll quickly find that they are both available for the same price.

I also love how Sudsy Bear gives you a lot of options for payment. You can pay through Paypal (which I don’t like), Shop Pay, Amazon Pay, Google Pay, or pay using your credit card.

Dr. Squatch also allows you to pay through their site with similar payment methods except Amazon Pay, which is not a big deal.

I find that to be similar, which isn’t bad. Finally, the size of both soaps is the same, so there seems to be no difference at all here.

Reviews & Popularity

In terms of popularity, the Dr. Squatch Bay Rum is more popular and a best seller too. So, you can find more reviews on it than the Sudsy Bear soap.

Dr. Squatch Bay Rum is available on Amazon, Walmart, and a few other popular stores, which makes shopping easier.

From my research, it seems you’ll only be able to order the Sudsy Bear Rum from the website.

I consider that a plus because sometimes, you don’t get all the information you want on the manufacturer’s website and only rely on info from other users.

The more the reviews, then, the easier it is to decide if the soap is for you or not.

Frequently Asked Questions:

How long does sudsy bear soap last?

According to the brand, the soap should last for 4 to 5 weeks, depending on your showering habit. This is similar to how long Dr. Squatch soap will last too. That makes sense, considering they’re both available in 5oz.

Is Dr. Squatch better?

By popular demand, it looks like that. But your experience may differ so you may need to experiment to come to terms with one of them.

Final Thoughts

  • Both products are man-made with natural and organic ingredients. All ingredients are naturally & sustainably contained by Mother Nature.
  • They contain no abrasives, harsh chemicals, or unpronounceable names.
  • Sudsy Bear Rum added exfoliant to the soaps.
  • Sudsy Bear also seems to have better scents that last longer.
  • Dr. Squatch Bay Rum soaps tend to dissolve quicker when compared with Sudsy Bear.
  • Dr. Squatch Soap is pricier than average products.

Based on the review, both have similar ingredients, smells, and benefits for the skin. However, feel free to do simple skin tests to get which fits perfectly with your body.

Read Next: Dr. Squatch Scents Ranked

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *